From the reports «Climate change, ocean processes and ocean iron fertilization«, by K. L. Denman, published at Inter-research, «Globalizing results from ocean in situ iron fertilization studies«, by O. Aumont and L. Bopp, published at Global Biochemical Cycles, and «Reviews and syntheses: Ocean iron fertilization experiments – past, present, and future looking to a future Korean Iron Fertilization Experiment in the Southern Ocean (KIFES) project«, by Joo-Eun Yoon, Kyu-Cheul Yoo, Alison M. Macdonald, Ho-Il Yoon, Ki-Tae Park, Eun Jin Yang, Hyun-Cheol Kim, Jae Il Lee, Min Kyung Lee, Jinyoung Jung, Jisoo Park, Jiyoung Lee, Soyeon Kim, Seong-Su Kim, Kitae Kim, and Il-Nam Kim, published at Biogeosciences.
Across all three studies, artificial iron fertilization in HNLC regions consistently stimulates phytoplankton growth and alters community structure, but its effectiveness in exporting carbon to depths below the winter mixed layer is very limited. Yoon et al. (2018) note that only EIFEX showed a clear increase in deep carbon export, while most experiments produced strong surface blooms without significant long-term sequestration. Denman (2008) emphasizes that increasingly realistic global models predict small sequestration relative to projected fossil‑fuel emissions.

Aumont & Bopp (2006) provide detailed modeling showing that even large‑scale, continuous fertilization would sequester only about 70 PgC by 2100, and less than 7 PgC if fertilization stops after 10 years. More recent models cited by Denman (2008) yield even lower values. These results indicate that iron fertilization could offset only a small fraction of anthropogenic emissions and would require sustained application, with potential reductions in long‑term ocean productivity due to nutrient redistribution.
All three sources highlight possible side effects: increased remineralization and N₂O production, changes in food‑web structure, shifts toward diatom dominance, altered DMS dynamics, and risks of hypoxia and acidification. They conclude that iron fertilization remains scientifically valuable for studying ocean ecosystems but cannot be considered an effective or reliable climate‑mitigation strategy under current evidence.
